Home/Voices/The chefs

Chef

Patrick O’Connell

Chef of The Inn at Little Washington in Virginia, on the orchestra, the rehearsal and the healing art form.


When I spoke with Patrick O’Connell, he was the chef of The Inn at Little Washington in Virginia, which holds three Michelin stars and operates as both a restaurant and a Relais & Châteaux property, one of the most influential restaurant with rooms operations in modern American hospitality. In The Luxury of Attention he gives the disciplined team a metaphor I have kept, and he gives the human touch its most philosophical statement.

His first job was in a restaurant at fifteen, and he told me he was hooked once he discovered the intensity of the business. What he fell in love with was restaurant people, with their odd humor and their appreciation for the absurdities of life, and the sense of watching two shows at once: the fantasy in the dining room and the rough world of the kitchen behind it. After more than four decades he still finds the adrenaline of service exhilarating.

The idea he carries in Chapter 4 is the team as an orchestra. The Inn, he said, is united around a common goal of excellence without compromise, and the key word for him is collaboration. Everyone’s contribution matters and everyone has to be on cue.

“It’s very much like an orchestra and my role is parallel to a conductor’s. I’m always looking for any flaws and imperfections that need correction.” Patrick O’Connell, chef of The Inn at Little Washington, Virginia

What I take from the metaphor is the rehearsal. The musicians are trained separately before they join the orchestra, and the daily, repeated rehearsal is what aligns their separate trainings into the single performance the audience pays for. A new musician rushed past the rehearsal will be audible in the section for months, and the same is true of a new line cook or a new front desk agent. The orchestra does not skip the rehearsal. In his earlier profile O’Connell adds the conductor’s other duty, which is to be the restaurant’s worst critic and to see the evening as an unforgiving guest would.

In Chapter 8 he describes the work, in its highest sense, as a healing art form. The plate, the room, the welcome and the moment of departure are each a chance for the operation to register what the diner needs and respond to it specifically, so that the diner who arrives exhausted from a difficult week gets a different evening from the one who arrives celebrating. The kitchen and the floor calibrate together. The phrasing is grand, and the discipline beneath it is the same specific noticing the hoteliers in that chapter describe.

His earlier profile explains how the standard is kept moving. His approach is to make everything a little better than it was the day before, on the grounds that a restaurant is either growing or dying. Young cooks cook his dinner each night and he critiques it; anyone in the kitchen can put a dish in front of him for feedback, and the result is often a hybrid nobody can take sole credit for.

“Everything can always be improved. You never arrive in our business. After 40 years, I still say that we’re about 60 percent of the way there.” Patrick O’Connell, in A Wealth of Insight (2019)

If the people at the top believe they are 60 percent of the way there, the people below them will keep looking for the next improvement.

In the book, Patrick O’Connell appears in Chapter 4, First the Team, on the orchestra, the conductor and the rehearsal; and in Chapter 8, The Human Touch, on the kitchen and the floor calibrating together to give each guest the evening they need. Patrick’s full profile, in his own words, runs 6 pages in A Wealth of Insight: The World’s Best Chefs (2019).

The full profile, in Patrick O’Connell's own words

This is the complete profile of Patrick O’Connell as published in A Wealth of Insight: The World's Best Chefs on Creativity, Leadership, and Perfection, reproduced word for word. The section headings are the book's. The profile ran on pages 166 to 171. Titles and positions are as they stood at the time of the interview.

Absurdities of Life

My first job was in a restaurant at the impressionable age of 15. Once I discovered the intensity of this delicious business, I was hooked. More than anything, I fell in love with restaurant people. They all seemed to have a whacked sense of humor and a genuine appreciation for the absurdities of life. Every day I felt like I was watching a split-screen film with two shows running simultaneously—the fantasy taking place in the dining room juxtaposed with what was going on behind the scenes in the rough and tumble world of the kitchen. I’ve never been bored for a minute in a restaurant kitchen. I love getting into “the zone” and forgetting I have a body or any problems. Every night I still find the addictive adrenaline rush exhilarating.

Very Much Like an Orchestra

The team is united around a common goal of excellence without compromise. For me the key word is collaboration. Everyone’s contribution is important and everyone has to be on cue. It’s very much like an orchestra and my role is parallel to a conductor’s. I’m always looking for any flaws and imperfections in our performance. It’s important to understand how unforgiving a guest can be if something isn’t as it should be. My role is to be our worst critic and to see the experience as a critical guest would view it.

Growing or Dying

One of the biggest challenges any restaurateur faces these days is the need to constantly re-invent themselves while still maintaining continuity and consistency. On each visit there needs to be a fresh surprise for the guest. An artist’s work must reflect his or her taste at any given moment or it will register as inauthentic or stale. If a chef is bored with a dish it will be felt by the guest.

In its highest sense, I regard my work as a healing art form.

Our approach is simply to try to make everything a little bit better than it was the day before. Even the tiniest, incremental improvement brings a sense of satisfaction and is noticed by guests. Most importantly, it helps create a culture of upward ascendancy. The old adage that a restaurant is either growing or dying is deadly accurate. Standing still is dying.

You Never Arrive in Our Business

I often say that creativity can’t be taught, it has to be caught. Getting in touch with ones innate sense of creativity is often an unlearning process rather than a learning one. There is no formula. You might have to embrace the opposite of what you were told would work. When you’re nimble and open enough to follow an uncharted path it often leads you to a more original solution. Many great dishes have been concocted based on accidents and mistakes. Improvisation can often be freeing and a way to get in touch with your unconscious creativity. Everything can always be improved. You never arrive in our business. After 40 years, I still say that we’re about 60 percent of the way there.

Just Imagine

I have to eat here every night and I get bored quickly. The young cooks get to experiment on me by cooking my dinner. I critique their dishes and give them feedback. More often than not that begins a dialogue and an exchange of ideas.

Since our menu is continually evolving, we sometimes choose a dish on the current menu that best exemplifies our direction and ask ourselves how the other dishes measure up. If they don’t, we target them for replacement and someone begins working on a new alternative. The process usually takes weeks of critical tasting and evaluating to finally find its way on the menu. We sometimes bring back a dish we did 30 years ago, update it and breathe new life into it. Imagine the number of dishes we’ve created in more than 40 years with an ever-evolving seasonal menu.

It Was Reborn

For more than 25 years we’ve had a seared lamb carpaccio on the menu. Originally it was garnished with a little mound of tabouli in an era when few people knew what tabouli was. Then one day, it just felt tired. We eliminated the tabouli and inserted a garnish of caesar salad ice cream. It was an overnight sensation and gave new life to the dish. Eating it became an adventure. Everyone loved it. It was reborn. Sometimes we do a new take on a classic preparation such as our duck a l’orange reincarnated, eliminating everything heavy and out of fashion but keeping the essential essence and flavor profile.

Whose Idea Was That?

Sometimes a dish falls together spontaneously, but more often than not it’s a long process of working with the germ of an idea and refining it. Once conceptualized, It takes about one month for a dish to get ironed out and perfected.

Everyone in the kitchen is invited to put a dish in front of me at any time for feedback. Usually there is an element of originality or a feature which might trigger another idea and it’s often like a ping pong game. This is one of my favorite interactions with the team. It involves tapping into a collective consciousness. Sometimes it’s impossible to remember whose idea was whose. The end result is a hybrid and much better than any one person could have conceived on their own. This process requires everyone to be non-competitive and non-judgmental in order for it to work.

The Importance of Tradition

There is too little appreciation for quality, excellence, and tradition. My hope is that we don’t feel we have to throw away tradition entirely in order to embrace what’s new. One of the ways in which we can increase the appreciation for tradition is by educating food journalists and critics. Few of them have the international reference points necessary to formulate an historical perspective.

A Healing Art Form

For the past 40 years, I’ve been attempting to combine the disciplines of theatre, the culinary arts and psychology in the creation of a unique restorative sanctuary—a stage set for a magical interlude out of time and place where worldly cares can be suspended, our faith in humanity restored, and the art of living celebrated.

Words of Wisdom

My advice to young and aspiring chefs would be to become a voracious reader of restaurant reviews. Study the critics. Go to the best restaurants in your region and then in the world. Create reference points and benchmarks for yourself. Choose a chef and restaurant as a model of what you might wish to ultimately become. If you want to open a burger joint, don’t aim for the best hamburger in town or your state—go for the best hamburger in the world. Find a mentor and a critic, preferably someone who has a world view and who will be brutally honest with you.

The profile is one of the first person accounts collected in A Wealth of Insight: The World's Best Chefs (2019), the book that preceded The Luxury of Attention.